Skip to main content

Men Behaving Badly; Women and Children Too

When we visit the Netherlands or come across the Dutch abroad, we always feel they know how to relax and enjoy life. Visit Museum De Lakenhal in Leiden and you'll see in their latest exhibition that this joie de vivre has a long tradition. The gallery is looking back 400 years to the birth in the city of Jan Steen, who frequently painted his countrymen having a good time. And yes, on occasion, perhaps just a little bit too much of a good time.  In this show,  At Home with Jan Steen -- 400 Years of Merrymaking , you will discover why the Dutch use the expression "a Jan Steen household" for a home where, well, things are maybe just a bit too free and easy. This is the painting that sums it up: What a jolly time everyone is having in The Merry Family . To the accompaniment of music, they are indeed making merry: singing, drinking and smoking. All are taking part; the old, the young, and even a baby wielding a spoon. The baby's not partaking of the alcohol or tobacco, adm...

Subscribe to updates

The Renaissance Nude -- It's Not the Full Monty

Renaissance nudes.... let's see what springs to mind.

Well, there's Titian's Venus of Urbino, obviously, or maybe the Sleeping Venus started by Giorgione and finished by Titian. How about Botticelli's Birth of Venus, or Velázquez's Rokeby Venus, or one of those many Cranachs with Venus and Cupid? And that's just the one Roman goddess, off the top of our heads.

So, for an exhibition on the Renaissance Nude, at London's Royal Academy, organised in conjunction with the J Paul Getty Museum in Los Angeles, you might be expecting a bit of a blockbuster. But this show is a lot more low-key. There are some fine works of art, to be sure, with Raphael, Titian, Michelangelo and Leonardo represented, but it just all feels a wee bit flat.

You see, as we left, we were thinking about what pictures might have given a bit of oomph to this exhibition, and one of the first we came up with was Jean Fouquet's Virgin and Child from the Royal Museum of Fine Arts in Antwerp. A pale Virgin Mary, apparently modelled by Agnes Sorel, the mistress of King Charles VII of France, stands with one breast exposed, surrounded by astounding red and blue angels. Combining the religious with the aesthetic and the erotic, it's the sort of image that once seen is not easily forgotten. In short, the perfect Renaissance nude, or semi-nude. Maybe we should play this Fantasy Art Exhibition game a bit more often, because it turns out that the Virgin and Child was indeed the star attraction of the Getty version of this show during the winter.

Among other paintings that failed to make it from LA to the RA, we find from the Getty's checklist, are Antonello da Messina's St Sebastian from Dresden and Giorgione's Laura from Vienna, to name but two. What's going on here? Big pictures from big European galleries not being loaned to the Royal Academy?

These missing works do go some way to explaining why we felt a little bit short-changed by this show, despite its near-universal good reviews. 

So, now that we've told you what you're not getting, what can you see at the Royal Academy? One of the themes of this show is how religion and art were interlinked during the Renaissance, with the depiction of some episodes from both the Old Testament -- think Adam and Eve -- and the New giving artists the opportunity to depict nudes, making Christian subject matter more realistic.

Well, at least in theory. Because here are saints who remain beautiful despite the ordeals they are going through. Take Sebastian, according to tradition bound to a stake and shot through with arrows for his faith. One of the first paintings we encounter is of him by Cima da Conegliano; it's a male-model body and pose, and there's just the one arrow in his thigh. If he's idealised, he's nothing compared with this later version by Agnolo Bronzino, with the saint looking positively seductive in an off-the-shoulder red number.
There was of course even more leeway for the erotic in the depiction of classical gods and heroes, with their tales of lust and debauchery. Perhaps the outstanding picture here is Titian's Venus Rising from the Sea, with the goddess softly captured in a naturalistic pose, wringing out her wet hair and glancing over her shoulder.
There are other paintings, though, that left us cold: Dosso Dossi's Myth of Pan, over from the Getty, hardly seems like one of the great works of the Renaissance, with its unconvincing figures and cluttered composition. That's one of two large canvases by Dossi, and there's quite a lot, too, of Jan Gossaert's rather oddly proportioned, contorted nudes.

Some of the best bits of this show are not the paintings, but the prints and drawings. In Albrecht Dürer's Bath House, lots of steamy looks are being exchanged among the muscly male bathers. One of them leans on a post behind a suggestively placed tap. Where Dürer is all angular realism, Raphael's Three Graces are full of the curves of beauty, perhaps the most sinuously seductive image in this entire exhibition.
And among the most vivid representations of the human body in the Renaissance were those by Leonardo da Vinci, who dissected corpses as part of his researches into anatomy. This sheet explores the shoulder and neck muscles, annotated with Leonardo's notes in mirror script.
We go to exhibitions for a number of reasons. Sometimes we see great masterpieces from far-flung museums (how astounding it was to see American Gothic in the same rooms at the RA a couple of years ago). Sometimes we learn things, get a new take on the familiar (as in the Hammershøi show now on in Paris) or meet an artist completely unknown to us (the Harold Gilman exhibition in Chichester, for example). And sometimes we are just enthralled and entertained. Unfortunately, the naked truth is that the Renaissance Nude didn't really do any of that for us. Perhaps we should have got the Stephen Fry-voiced audioguide to bring to life what we found rather a lacklustre and pedestrian affair. 

Practicalities

Renaissance Nude runs until June 2 at the Royal Academy on Piccadilly in central London. It's open daily from 1000 to 1800, with lates on Fridays until 2200. Full-price tickets are £16, or £14 without a Gift Aid donation. Online booking is available here. The RA is a few minutes' walk from Green Park and Piccadilly Circus Tube stations.

Images

Agnolo Bronzino, Saint Sebastian, c. 1533, Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza, Madrid
Titian, Venus Rising from the Sea (Venus Anadyomene), c. 1520, National Galleries of Scotland, Edinburgh
Raphael, The Three Graces, c. 1517-18, Royal Collection Trust. © Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II 2019
Leonardo da Vinci, The Anatomy of the Shoulder and Neck, c. 1510-11, Royal Collection Trust. © Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II 2019


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Highs and Lows of the Nahmad Collection

It's widely referred to as the world's most valuable private art collection : the one assembled over decades by the Nahmad brothers, dealers Ezra and David . Worth an estimated $3 billion or more, it's said to include hundreds of Picassos. Some 60 works from it are now on display at the Musée des impressionnismes in Giverny as  The Nahmad Collection: From Monet to Picasso . Intended, apparently, to demonstrate how art developed from the early 19th century through Impressionism and on to the start of the modern era, towards the liberation of colour and form, this is an exhibition that ends up coming across as somewhat incoherent. We're not really told much about the Nahmads or their collecting choices -- and as you search the Internet, things become slightly mysterious: Is Ezra alive or dead? The art, presumably, is supposed to speak for itself, but it's a rather eclectic, if not confusing, selection; some of the works are fantastic, some are distinctly ho-hum.  Let...

What's On in 2025

What will be the exhibition highlights of 2025 around Britain and Europe? At the end of the year, Tate Britain will be marking 250 years since the birth of JMW Turner and John Constable with a potential blockbuster. Meanwhile, the Swiss are  making a big thing  of the 100th anniversary of the death of Félix Vallotton  (a real favourite of ours). Among women artists in the spotlight will be Anna Ancher, Ithell Colquhoun, Artemisia Gentileschi and Suzanne Valadon. Here's a selection of what's coming up, in more or less chronological order; as ever, we make no claim to comprehensiveness, and our choice very much reflects our personal taste. And in our search for the most interesting shows, we're visiting Ascona, Baden-Baden, Chemnitz and Winterthur, among other places.  January  We start off in Paris, at the Pompidou Centre; the 1970s inside-out building is showing its age and it'll be shut in the summer for a renovation programme scheduled to last until 2030. Bef...

What's On in 2026

Coming up in 2026: Lots more big exhibitions starring women artists, including Frida Kahlo, Leonor Fini, Leonora Carrington and Gwen John , as well as a host of names from the 17th-century Low Countries. And women almost certainly embroidered the Bayeux Tapestry, a contender for this year's hottest ticket in London.   Here's a selection of shows that have caught our eye around Britain and Europe, in more or less chronological order; as ever, we make no claim to comprehensiveness, and our choice very much reflects our personal taste. January We'll start the year at the Fondation Beyeler on the outskirts of Basel, where they're devoting an exhibition to Paul Cezanne . Focusing on the artist's later years, the show will bring together some 80 oil paintings and watercolours. January 25 to May 25.  February Two leading British women artists feature in exhibitions opening this month, with the National Museum in Cardiff honouring the best-known female painter Wales has pr...